Defense Lawyer
Boston OUI and DUI Defense Lawyer
A person arrested for operating under the influence, or OUI, in Boston or a nearby city must appear for a first court date, called the arraignment, in the court that covers the city or town where the driving took place. For an OUI in Boston, the arraignment takes place in one of the eight divisions of the Boston Municipal Court. For an OUI outside Boston, the arraignment takes place in the district court that covers the city or town. The release paperwork from the police station states the arraignment date, which is often the next court day.
A driver who refused the breath test must also go in person to the Registry of Motor Vehicles (“RMV”) Haymarket Service Center in Boston within 15 days of the refusal to request a hearing on the refusal suspension. Attorney Joe Serpa’s office telephone number is (617) 936-0201.
The RMV holds refusal hearings only at Haymarket, on a walk-in basis. The hearings officer decides only whether the police officer had reasonable grounds to believe the driver was operating under the influence, whether the officer arrested the driver, and whether the driver refused the test. G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(g). The RMV must reinstate the license if the hearings officer decides any one of those three questions in the driver’s favor. A driver who misses the 15-day deadline loses the right to the RMV hearing on the refusal suspension.
A driver who took the breath test and produced a breath test final analysis of .08 or greater, or .02 or greater for a driver under 21, loses the license until the case ends or for 30 days, whichever occurs first. G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(f)(2).
G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(g) provides one hearing on the 30-day suspension, in the court where the OUI charge is pending. The driver must request the court hearing within 10 days of the suspension. At the hearing, the judge decides only whether a blood test taken within a reasonable time after the breath test showed a blood alcohol percentage below .08, or below .02 for a driver under 21.
Attorney Serpa has practiced Massachusetts criminal defense since 1995. He represents drivers at arraignment, at pretrial hearings, and at trial in the Boston Municipal Court and the district courts of Greater Boston, from offices at 20 Park Plaza, Suite 400A, in Boston and 500 Victory Road, Suite 400A, in Quincy. He handles the criminal case and advises clients on the RMV hearings, but he does not appear with clients at the RMV.
The Criminal Case in Court
The police apply for a criminal complaint after an OUI arrest. The clerk-magistrate issues the complaint on a finding of probable cause. At the arraignment, the judge enters a plea of not guilty for the defendant and sets the conditions of release. The district attorney’s office prosecutes the case from the arraignment forward. The case then proceeds through pretrial conferences, discovery, and motions to a negotiated resolution or a trial before a judge or a jury.
A driver who received a summons instead of an arrest may first face a clerk-magistrate hearing in the OUI case. The firm’s court pages describe OUI cases in the Brookline, Cambridge, Chelsea, Concord, Dedham, Framingham, Hingham, Malden, Newton, Quincy, Somerville, Waltham, Woburn, and Wrentham District Courts. The article What Happens After an OUI Arrest in Massachusetts describes each stage of an OUI case, from booking to the end of the case.
What the Commonwealth Must Prove
The Commonwealth must prove three elements beyond a reasonable doubt. The driver operated a motor vehicle. The operation occurred on a public way or in a place to which the public has access. The driver was under the influence of alcohol or drugs, or had a blood alcohol level of .08 or greater. G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(a)(1).
A person can operate a vehicle without driving it, so the defense often contests operation when the police find a driver parked or asleep. The article on OUI in a parked car explains the operation element. The Massachusetts OUI and DUI FAQs answer common questions about the charge.
The Breath Test and the Breath Test Refusal
Massachusetts police use the Draeger Alcotest 9510 to produce the breath test final analysis. A judge can exclude the breath test final analysis when the Commonwealth cannot establish its foundation, including the device certification, the calibration records, and the required testing sequence. The firm’s pages on breathalyzer defense and breath test and blood alcohol science explain the instrument and the regulations. The article on Commonwealth v. Hallinan explains the Alcotest exclusion litigation.
The RMV suspends the license of a driver age 21 or older with no prior OUI for 180 days after a breath test refusal. G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(f)(1). Drivers under 21 and drivers with prior offenses face longer refusal suspensions. The Commonwealth cannot tell the jury that the driver refused the test. G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(e).
The page on breathalyzer tests and license suspensions covers the refusal suspension and its hearing. The page on incomplete breath tests and refusals explains when an incomplete test counts as a refusal. The article How I Try a Massachusetts OUI Case After a Breathalyzer Refusal describes the trial of a refusal case.
License Suspensions and Hardship Licenses
Each license suspension in an OUI case has its own legal source, length, and hearing. The RMV imposes the refusal suspension and the .08 suspension at the time of the arrest. After a conviction without a disposition under G.L. c. 90, § 24D, the RMV revokes the license for a period that depends on the driver’s prior offenses under § 24. Police can also ask the RMV to suspend a license as an immediate threat under G.L. c. 90, § 22(a), even without an arrest. The guide to OUI license suspensions and reinstatement and the OUI license suspension and RMV hearing FAQs explain each suspension.
A driver who receives a § 24D disposition may apply to the RMV for a hardship license as soon as the driver enrolls in the alcohol education program. The RMV decides in its discretion whether to issue the hardship license. The RMV requires an ignition interlock device as a condition of a first offender’s hardship license when the breath test final analysis was .15 or greater. The RMV imposes the interlock condition under G.L. c. 90, § 24D and under 540 CMR 25.07(1A). The hardship license guide and the hardship license FAQs explain eligibility, documents, and appeals.
A First Offense and the Section 24D Disposition
A defendant convicted of a first offense faces a fine of $500 to $5,000, up to two and one-half years in a house of correction, or both. Most first offenders resolve the case under G.L. c. 90, § 24D.
The judge places an eligible defendant on probation for up to two years and orders a driver alcohol education program. The judge suspends the license for 45 to 90 days, or for 210 days when the driver was under 21, as part of the § 24D disposition. The RMV revokes the license of a first offender convicted without § 24D for one year.
The page on a first offense OUI in Massachusetts explains the § 24D disposition, the hardship license, and the record that remains. The article on the Section 24D disposition covers the program in detail.
Second and Later Offenses
A defendant convicted of a second offense faces a fine of $600 to $10,000 and 60 days to two and one-half years in a house of correction, with at least 30 days served. G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(a)(1). The judge may instead place a second offender who consents on probation with a 14-day residential treatment program. G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(a)(4). The RMV ordinarily revokes the license for two years after a second-offense conviction. A third or later offense is a felony.
A driver whose only prior OUI was 10 years or more before the new offense may receive a second § 24D disposition once in a lifetime. Commonwealth v. Cahill, 442 Mass. 127. The page on second-offense OUI and the Cahill disposition and the Cahill and second Section 24D FAQs explain that disposition.
Defending an OUI Case
The defense examines the police report, the cruiser and booking video, the breath test records, and the field sobriety evidence. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration manual for the field sobriety tests contains no failing score. The Commonwealth must present expert testimony before a jury hears evidence of the horizontal gaze nystagmus test. Commonwealth v. Sands, 424 Mass. 184. The firm’s pages on field sobriety test defense and cross-examining the field sobriety opinion explain the roadside evidence.
A drug or marijuana OUI case depends on different evidence, because no breath test measures marijuana impairment. The page on marijuana and drug OUI defense explains the evidence in a drug OUI case. The page on sobriety checkpoints explains the rules for roadblocks. The article on how Massachusetts OUI cases are won at trial describes the defense at trial.
Recent OUI Results
OUI (Drugs), Assault and Resisting Arrest, Boston Municipal Court, Roxbury Division: OUI Resolved Under § 24D and Other Charges Dismissed (June 2026)
A Colorado State University graduate faced an OUI charge based on drugs, several assault charges and a resisting arrest charge. The OUI charge was resolved under the first-offender provision of G.L. c. 90, § 24D. All of the assault and resisting arrest charges were dismissed.
OUI, Boston Municipal Court, West Roxbury Division: Dismissed (April 2026)
A contractor’s OUI charge was dismissed.
OUI, Boston Municipal Court, Charlestown Division: Dismissed (April 2026)
A contractor’s OUI charge was dismissed.
OUI, Boston Municipal Court, West Roxbury Division: No Complaint (March 2026)
A retail manager faced an application for an OUI complaint. The clerk-magistrate denied the complaint application at a clerk-magistrate hearing.
The four entries above appear on the firm’s criminal defense results page, which lists recent results in every practice area. Each case depends on its own facts and evidence. Past results do not guarantee a future outcome.
Drivers From Out of State and Noncitizens
A driver licensed in another state faces separate license rules after a Massachusetts OUI arrest. The page on the out-of-state driver charged with OUI explains the interstate license rules. Noncitizens should read the page on OUI and immigration consequences before resolving the case. The page on traveling to Canada after an OUI covers Canadian entry rules.
Frequently Asked Questions About OUI Charges in Boston and Greater Boston
A first or second OUI offense is a misdemeanor. A third or later OUI offense is a felony under G.L. c. 90, § 24. A defendant convicted of a third offense serves at least 150 days and faces up to five years in state prison. A defendant convicted of a fourth offense serves at least one year. A defendant convicted of a fifth offense serves at least two years. OUI causing serious bodily injury under G.L. c. 90, § 24L(1) and motor vehicle homicide under G.L. c. 90, § 24G(a) are felonies on a first offense.
The three terms describe the same conduct. Massachusetts calls the offense operating under the influence, or OUI, because G.L. c. 90, § 24 uses the word operating rather than driving. Other states call the offense driving under the influence, or DUI, or driving while intoxicated, or DWI. A Massachusetts court record, a police report, and a Registry of Motor Vehicles notice all say OUI. A conviction for DUI or DWI in another state counts as a prior OUI offense in Massachusetts when the other state’s law prohibits the same conduct.
The Commonwealth can prove an alcohol OUI charge in either of two ways. On the impairment theory, the Commonwealth proves that alcohol diminished the driver’s ability to operate the vehicle safely. On the per se theory, the Commonwealth proves that the driver’s blood alcohol level was .08 percent or greater, usually through the breath test final analysis or a hospital blood record. The Commonwealth does not have to prove impairment on the per se theory. The Commonwealth does not have to prove a blood alcohol level on the impairment theory. A jury may convict on either theory.
Yes. When there is no breath test final analysis, the Commonwealth proceeds on the impairment theory. The Commonwealth proves impairment through the officer’s observations of the driving, the driver’s speech, balance, eyes, and odor of alcohol, the driver’s performance on the field sobriety tests, and any admission the driver made about drinking. The Commonwealth does not have to prove erratic driving. The Commonwealth must prove that alcohol diminished the driver’s capacity to drive safely. A jury may acquit when the observations have innocent explanations such as fatigue, injury, nerves, or a medical condition.
The Commonwealth must prove that the driver operated on a way or in a place to which the public has a right of access, or to which members of the public have access as invitees or licensees. A public street, a highway, and a store parking lot open to customers all qualify. A judge looks at objective signs such as paving, curbing, street lights, traffic signals, and abutting homes or businesses. A private lot behind a locked gate ordinarily does not qualify. A parcel posted against trespassers and used without the owner’s permission does not qualify.
Yes. The Commonwealth may prove operation through circumstantial evidence. A driver found alone in the driver’s seat with the key in the ignition, a warm engine, or the vehicle in gear can support a finding of operation. A driver’s admission to driving also supports the finding, but the Commonwealth must corroborate an admission with some other evidence that the crime occurred. The defense contests operation by showing that another person drove, that the driver never performed an act that could set the vehicle in motion, or that the admission is unreliable.
An officer who observed the driver may give an opinion about the driver’s level of sobriety, such as an opinion that the driver was intoxicated. The officer may not give an opinion on the ultimate question for the jury, which is whether alcohol impaired the driver’s ability to operate the vehicle safely. Commonwealth v. Canty sets that limit. The officer also may not testify that the driver passed or failed the field sobriety tests. Defense counsel objects when an officer crosses either line and cross-examines the officer on the observations behind the opinion.
Yes. Under G.L. c. 90, § 24, a prior offense includes a conviction or a court-ordered program assignment entered by a court of any other jurisdiction for a like violation. A DUI conviction in New Hampshire, Rhode Island, or any other state counts when a person is charged with a new OUI in Massachusetts. The prior offense raises the penalty, lengthens the Registry suspension, and can make a second offender subject to the ignition interlock requirement. A purely administrative action in another state, such as a refusal suspension entered by a motor vehicle agency with no court disposition, does not count.
In the consolidated Ananias litigation, a District Court judge found that the Office of Alcohol Testing had withheld failed calibration worksheets. The court established a presumption that the breath test final analysis from an Alcotest 9510 machine last calibrated and certified before April 18, 2019 is excluded from evidence. The breath test final analysis from a machine calibrated and certified on or after April 18, 2019 is admissible again. The defense may still challenge the reliability of the particular machine. The Commonwealth must still produce the certification and calibration records for that machine.
Yes. The police need a lawful reason to stop the vehicle, a lawful basis to order the driver out, and a lawful basis for each later step. A judge who finds that the stop or a later step was unlawful suppresses the officer’s observations and the other evidence the police obtained after that step. When the suppressed evidence includes the observations and the breath test final analysis, the Commonwealth often has nothing left with which to prove the charge. The case then ends in a dismissal.
The Commonwealth can add a charge under G.L. c. 90, § 24V when a child age 14 or younger was in the vehicle during the OUI offense. The Commonwealth does not have to prove that the child was hurt. A defendant convicted of a first offense under § 24V pays a fine of $1,000 to $5,000, serves 90 days to two and one-half years in a house of correction, and loses the license for one year. The sentence runs after the sentence for the OUI itself. The Commonwealth can also charge reckless endangerment of a child under G.L. c. 265, § 13L.
Yes. Canada treats impaired driving as a serious crime for immigration purposes. A Canadian border officer can refuse entry to a person with an OUI conviction. Canadian officers may also treat a continuance without a finding as a conviction because it rests on an admission to sufficient facts. A person who needs to travel to Canada can apply for a temporary resident permit. After enough time has passed since the sentence ended, the person can apply for criminal rehabilitation. A client who works or has family in Canada should raise the travel question before resolving the case, because the disposition affects the Canadian analysis.
Related Serpa Law Office resources
- First Offense OUI in Massachusetts
- Breathalyzer Tests and License Suspensions in Massachusetts
- Massachusetts OUI Hardship Licenses and Section 24D
- Second-Offense OUI and the Cahill Disposition in Massachusetts
- Massachusetts OUI License Suspensions and Reinstatement
- Massachusetts OUI and DUI FAQs
- Massachusetts OUI License Suspension and RMV Hearing FAQs
- Abogado de Defensa de OUI en Massachusetts
Last Reviewed: November 2026










