Malicious Destruction of Property in Massachusetts (G.L. c. 266, § 127)

Malicious destruction of property under G.L. c. 266, § 127 is a felony when the damage exceeds $1,200. The felony is punishable by up to ten years in state prison, or by a fine of $3,000 or three times the damage, whichever is greater, together with up to two and one-half years in jail. Malicious destruction is a misdemeanor when the damage is $1,200 or less. The misdemeanor is punishable by a fine of three times the damage or up to two and one-half years in the house of correction.

Wanton destruction is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of $1,000 or three times the damage, whichever is greater, or up to two and one-half years in the house of correction. Police may seek the charge after a domestic argument even when no one alleges a physical assault. The police report may describe a broken phone, a damaged door, a hole in a wall, or an object thrown across a room.

The statute covers injury to another person’s personal property, dwelling house, or building. Section 127 also includes electronically stored or transmitted data in the definition of personal property.

The precise charge depends on the defendant’s state of mind and, for felony treatment, the amount of damage. The defendant’s state of mind and the amount of damage each require separate evidence.

Two Different Offenses: Malicious and Wanton Destruction

Section 127 creates two distinct crimes, willful and malicious destruction of property and wanton destruction of property.

Malicious destruction and wanton destruction are not simply two degrees of the same offense. Wanton destruction is not automatically a lesser-included offense of malicious destruction. The Commonwealth must charge and prove the theory on which it seeks a conviction.

Willful and Malicious Destruction of Property

Under the Massachusetts model jury instruction, the Commonwealth must prove four elements beyond a reasonable doubt.

  1. The defendant injured or destroyed another person’s personal property, dwelling house, or building.
  2. The defendant acted willfully.
  3. The defendant acted with malice.
  4. In a case alleging damage over $1,200, the reasonable repair or replacement cost exceeded $1,200.

“Willful” means that the act was intentional and by design, rather than thoughtless or accidental. A willful act requires an intent to engage in the conduct and to cause its harmful result.

“Malice” means that the defendant acted deliberately out of cruelty, hostility, or revenge toward another person. The hostility need not be directed at the owner of the damaged property, but it must be more than carelessness or an intentional act that caused incidental damage.

Wanton Destruction of Property

The wanton-destruction instruction requires proof that the defendant injured or destroyed property of another and acted wantonly. In a case alleging damage over $1,200, the Commonwealth must also prove that amount beyond a reasonable doubt.

Wanton conduct is intentional conduct that disregards the probability of substantial property damage. The Commonwealth may prove that the defendant knew of the risk or that a reasonable person, knowing what the defendant knew, would have recognized it.

Negligence is not enough to prove wanton destruction. An accident also does not become wanton destruction merely because it caused expensive damage.

The Difference Between Malicious and Wanton Destruction

Malicious destruction requires an intent to cause the harmful result and the required cruel, hostile, or vengeful state of mind. Wanton destruction instead requires proof that the defendant intentionally disregarded a serious risk.

For example, evidence that a person deliberately aimed an object at a television may support a malicious theory. Evidence that the person threw the object without intending to hit anything may support a wanton theory if substantial damage was a probable result.

Damage that occurs while a person is pursuing a different purpose does not necessarily establish malice. The prosecution must prove the required state of mind with evidence beyond the fact that something broke.

The $1,200 Felony Threshold

OffenseClassificationMaximum penalty under G.L. c. 266, § 127
Willful and malicious destruction, damage over $1,200FelonyState prison up to 10 years, or a fine of $3,000 or three times the damage, whichever is greater, and jail up to 2½ years
Willful and malicious destruction, damage of $1,200 or lessMisdemeanorA fine of three times the damage or imprisonment up to 2½ years
Wanton destructionMisdemeanorA fine of $1,000 or three times the damage, whichever is greater, or imprisonment up to 2½ years

Willful and malicious destruction involving damage of more than $1,200 is a felony because the statute authorizes a state-prison sentence of up to ten years. The alternative punishment is a fine of $3,000 or three times the damage, whichever is greater, together with up to two and one-half years in jail. The judge holds an evidentiary hearing after conviction to determine the value of the damage when the fine is based on that value.

The malicious offense is a misdemeanor when the damage does not exceed $1,200. The misdemeanor is punishable by up to two and one-half years in a house of correction or a fine of three times the damage. Wanton destruction is a misdemeanor because its punishment does not include state prison.

The $1,200 threshold applies to the amount of damage, not the total price of the house, vehicle, or other item. The usual measure of damage to property that can be repaired is the reasonable cost of the repairs made necessary by the conduct.

Reasonable replacement cost may be the measure if repair is not possible. A store listing for a newer item, an unsupported estimate, or a dollar amount repeated in a police report may not establish the statutory value by itself.

The Commonwealth must prove value beyond a reasonable doubt when it seeks the greater offense. Receipts, estimates, photographs, testimony about condition, and evidence of depreciation may all be offered.

What Counts as the Property “of Another”?

A person does not violate Section 127 by damaging property that belongs exclusively to that person. The Commonwealth must identify the property and prove that it was the property of another.

Ownership in a household is not always obvious. Ownership of a phone, vehicle, appliance, or part of a residence depends on title, purchase records, possession, gifts, leases, and the parties’ respective interests.

Joint ownership or a marriage does not by itself establish whether an item is the property of another. The defense should examine the specific property interest instead of assuming that the item belonged exclusively to either person.

Property Damage in a Domestic Violence Case

Property destruction can be charged by itself or alongside assault and battery on a family or household member, threats to commit a crime, or another offense. The relationship between the parties is not an element of Section 127.

Under G.L. c. 276, § 56A, however, a judge who releases or admits to bail a defendant arrested for a crime against property must first ask the Commonwealth whether domestic abuse is alleged in connection with the crime.

The judge must make a written ruling that abuse is alleged in connection with the charged offense when the Commonwealth files a preliminary written statement alleging abuse. A ruling under § 56A can affect how the case is recorded, even though Section 127 does not require a family or dating relationship.

The Commonwealth may also charge witness intimidation if a phone was damaged to prevent a report, interfere with an investigation, or retaliate against a witness. The Commonwealth must separately prove the intent or reckless disregard that the witness intimidation statute requires.

The same conduct may be offered in a civil 209A restraining order (abuse prevention order) proceeding. The civil restraining order proceeding and the criminal case are separate cases, with different issues and burdens of proof.

Evidence When the Complainant Does Not Testify

A photograph that shows visible damage does not prove every element. The Commonwealth must still connect the defendant to the act and prove ownership, state of mind, and value when value is disputed.

A responding officer may describe what the officer personally observed. Repeating what an absent complainant said presents separate questions involving hearsay, excited utterances, and the Confrontation Clause.

A prosecutor may also rely on video, messages, admissions, repair records, or another witness. Each item must be authenticated and admitted under the rules of evidence.

Arrest, Clerk-Magistrate Hearing, and Arraignment

Some cases begin with an arrest and proceed directly to arraignment. Others begin with an application for a criminal complaint.

The defense can contest probable cause before a complaint issues when a clerk-magistrate hearing under G.L. c. 218, § 35A is available. A hearing is not available in every procedural posture.

Repairing or paying for the property may be relevant to a negotiated resolution, but the defendant should handle any repair or payment carefully. Counsel should review the amount, timing, and proposed written terms before anyone sends money or messages. Counsel should also consider how a payment or message could be used as evidence and whether a 209A restraining order prohibits contact.

After arraignment, a dismissal does not remove the charge from the court record. The available next steps depend on the disposition and are addressed on the firm’s page about Massachusetts criminal records.

Defenses to a Section 127 Charge

Defense counsel should compare the evidence with each element of the charge. The common defenses are listed below.

  • Accident. The act or the damage was not intentional, and the conduct was not wanton.
  • No malice. The damage was incidental to another act, or the evidence does not prove cruelty, hostility, or revenge.
  • No substantial-risk evidence. A wanton charge requires more than ordinary negligence or an unlikely possibility of damage.
  • Insufficient proof of value. The prosecution cannot establish reasonable repair or replacement cost above $1,200.
  • Ownership dispute. The evidence does not prove that the property belonged to another person.
  • Identity or causation. The Commonwealth cannot prove who caused the damage or when it occurred.
  • Incomplete or inadmissible evidence. A statement, photograph, estimate, or digital record may lack the necessary foundation.

Restitution and Other Consequences

A court may order restitution as part of a criminal disposition when the legal requirements are met. The amount must be tied to loss caused by the offense. The defendant has a right to contest the claimed loss and ability to pay.

A felony allegation can have immediate employment, licensing, education, immigration, and firearms consequences. A misdemeanor domestic-abuse allegation can also have consequences beyond the sentence. Counsel should review those consequences with the client before a plea, admission, or continuance without a finding.

The firm’s page on domestic-violence charges and immigration explains why a noncitizen needs an individualized analysis of the statute, the charging language, and the proposed disposition.

How Attorney Serpa Approaches the Defense

Attorney Serpa begins the review with the damaged item and the exact theory charged. Attorney Serpa examines photographs and recordings, ownership and repair records, and witness accounts. He also reconstructs the complete sequence of events before and after the alleged damage.

The defense may focus on preventing a complaint, reducing a felony allegation, challenging an element before trial, or obtaining a disposition that accounts for the client’s record and professional circumstances. The appropriate objective depends on the evidence and the client’s priorities.

Serpa Law Office represents people facing property-damage and domestic violence charges in Massachusetts. For a confidential consultation, call 617.936.0201.

Frequently Asked Questions About Property Damage Charges

Can I be charged for breaking a phone I paid for or that we owned together?

Yes, if the Commonwealth proves the phone was the property of another. A defendant does not violate Section 127 by damaging property that belongs exclusively to the defendant. A phone bought for a partner, held on a shared account, or given as a gift, however, can be the other person’s property. Joint ownership does not by itself establish whether the phone was the property of another. The Commonwealth must prove the ownership interest as an element. Title, purchase records, possession, and the parties’ arrangements are the evidence on both sides.

What if the damage was under $1,200?

A Section 127 charge involving damage of $1,200 or less is a misdemeanor. Willful and malicious destruction with damage of $1,200 or less is punishable by a fine of three times the damage or up to two and one-half years in the house of correction. Wanton destruction is punishable by a fine of $1,000 or three times the damage, whichever is greater, or up to two and one-half years. The Commonwealth must prove the amount beyond a reasonable doubt when it charges the felony. The measure of the damage is the reasonable cost of repair, or replacement where repair is impossible, not the price of a new item.

Is malicious destruction of property a felony in Massachusetts?

It depends on the amount of damage. Willful and malicious destruction of property is a felony under G.L. c. 266, § 127 when the damage exceeds $1,200, because the statute allows a state prison sentence. Malicious destruction with damage of $1,200 or less is a misdemeanor. Wanton destruction of property is a misdemeanor at any amount, because its punishment does not include state prison. The Commonwealth must prove the amount of damage beyond a reasonable doubt when it charges the felony, and the threshold applies to the cost of the damage, not the value of the whole car, house, or item.

What is the penalty for malicious destruction of property in Massachusetts?

A defendant convicted of willful and malicious destruction of property with damage over $1,200 faces up to ten years in state prison, or a fine of $3,000 or three times the damage, whichever is greater, together with up to two and one-half years in jail. A defendant convicted of malicious destruction with damage of $1,200 or less faces a fine of three times the damage or up to two and one-half years in a house of correction. A defendant convicted of wanton destruction faces a fine of $1,000 or three times the damage, whichever is greater, or up to two and one-half years in a house of correction.

What is the difference between malicious and wanton destruction of property?

Malicious destruction requires proof that the defendant acted willfully, meaning intentionally and by design, and with malice, meaning out of cruelty, hostility, or revenge toward another person. Wanton destruction requires proof that the defendant intentionally engaged in conduct while disregarding a probable risk of substantial property damage. A person who deliberately aims an object at a television may face a malicious charge. A person who throws the object without aiming at anything may face a wanton charge when substantial damage was a probable result. Section 127 creates two separate crimes. The Commonwealth must prove the theory it charges.

What does the Commonwealth have to prove for malicious destruction of property?

Four elements, each beyond a reasonable doubt. First, the defendant injured or destroyed the personal property, dwelling house, or building of another person. Second, the defendant acted willfully. Third, the defendant acted with malice. Fourth, for the felony, the reasonable cost of repair or replacement exceeded $1,200. Willful means intentional and by design, not thoughtless or accidental. Malice means that the defendant acted deliberately out of cruelty, hostility, or revenge toward another person. Damage that happens while a person pursues a different purpose does not by itself prove malice.

How does the Commonwealth prove the $1,200 amount in a property damage case?

By evidence of the reasonable cost of the repairs the conduct made necessary, or the reasonable replacement cost when repair is not possible. Receipts, written estimates, photographs, testimony about the condition of the item, and evidence of depreciation are the usual proof. A price for a newer model, an unsupported estimate, or a figure repeated in a police report does not by itself prove the statutory amount. The Commonwealth must prove the amount beyond a reasonable doubt to obtain a felony conviction. When the Commonwealth cannot, the charge is the misdemeanor.

Can I be charged with destruction of property for breaking something during an argument with my spouse?

Yes. The police commonly charge malicious or wanton destruction after a domestic argument in which a phone, a door, a wall, or a television was damaged, even when no one alleges a physical assault. The relationship is not an element of § 127, but under G.L. c. 276, § 56A the judge asks at arraignment whether abuse is alleged. A written ruling that abuse is alleged then follows the case in the domestic violence record keeping system. Taking or breaking a phone to stop a call to the police can also be charged as intimidation of a witness under G.L. c. 268, § 13B.

Is it a crime in Massachusetts to break my own property?

No. Section 127 punishes injury to the property of another. A person who damages property that belongs only to that person commits no crime under § 127. Ownership inside a household is often disputed. Who paid for a phone, whose name is on the lease or the title, who received an item as a gift, and whether an item was jointly owned all bear on whether the property was the property of another. A marriage or joint ownership does not by itself answer the question, and the defense examines the specific property interest before conceding the element.

Can I be charged with malicious destruction if it was an accident?

An accident is not malicious destruction and is not wanton destruction. Malicious destruction requires an intentional act done out of cruelty, hostility, or revenge. Wanton destruction requires intentional conduct that disregards a probable risk of substantial damage. Negligence is not enough. An expensive accident does not become wanton destruction because of its cost. The Commonwealth must prove the state of mind with evidence beyond the fact that something broke. Accident is a complete defense when the evidence leaves reasonable doubt on that element.

Will I have to pay restitution in a Massachusetts property damage case?

A judge may order restitution as part of a criminal disposition, but only for loss caused by the offense, and the defendant has a right to a hearing to contest the amount and to show an inability to pay. Repair or payment before the case ends can support a negotiated resolution, but the defendant should let counsel handle the amount, the timing, and the written terms. A payment or a message about payment can become evidence. A 209A restraining order may also bar any contact with the owner.

Can a malicious destruction charge end before arraignment in Massachusetts?

Yes, in two ways. A person who was not arrested has a right to a clerk-magistrate hearing on a misdemeanor application under G.L. c. 218, § 35A, and a denial means no complaint, no arraignment, and no CORI entry. For a misdemeanor property damage charge, the owner may also sign an accord and satisfaction under G.L. c. 276, § 55 acknowledging payment for the damage. The judge may then discharge the defendant. A case that begins with an arrest goes directly to arraignment, where counsel addresses the conditions of release and the evidence.

Related Serpa Law Office Resources

Client Reviews

He's one of the best people I've met. I'm really appreciative of all the help I received. If you have a serious case, he'll work hard to make sure you have the best outcome. I highly recommend him. You will not be disappointed.

A.J

Mr. Serpa was very helpful with my family member ‘s case. He was able to get it dismissed quickly and easily. He is very professional and very good at what he does. I’m so glad he hired him. You will be glad too if you hire him.

Z.M.

Serpa law office was my attorney of choice for 2 seperate cases I had last year. With both situations, Joseph not only treated me great, delivered the results I was hoping for, and was extremely professional and genuine. I would definitely recommend this law office to anyone in need of legal help.

P.C.

Greater Boston Criminal Law Alerts

Matthew Farwell Convicted in the Death of Sandra Birchmore: The Evidence, the Elements and the Verdict

By Attorney Joe Serpa | Georgetown University Law Center On Tuesday, November 10, 2026, a federal jury in Boston found former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell guilty on both counts of the superseding indictment that charged him in the death of Sandra Birchmore, according to WBUR. Count One charged him with killing a witness or…

Judge Denies Lindsay Clancy’s Double Jeopardy Motion: The November 9, 2026 Rulings

By Attorney Joe Serpa | Georgetown University Law Center On Monday, November 9, 2026, Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss the murder charges on double jeopardy grounds. He also denied her request for records about the holdout juror and her request to question that juror under oath. He denied the Commonwealth’s request…

Lindsay Clancy Hearing on November 2, 2026 and the Double Jeopardy Motion

On November 2, 2026, Judge William Sullivan heard the Lindsay Clancy double jeopardy motion and indicated that a second trial could begin in March 2027.

Contact Us

  1. 1 Individual, Hands-On Approach
  2. 2 Winning Trial Record
  3. 3 Criminal Defense Since 1995
Fill out the contact form or call us at 617.936.0201 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message

We Accept the Following Payment Solutions