Defense Lawyer
Threats to Commit a Crime in Massachusetts (G.L. c. 275, § 2)
Massachusetts law makes it a crime to threaten an unlawful injury to another person or another person’s property. Threats to commit a crime under G.L. c. 275, § 2 is a misdemeanor punishable under § 4 by a fine of up to $100 or up to six months in the house of correction. The judge may instead order a recognizance to keep the peace for up to six months. The charge is commonly brought after an argument, a text exchange, a social-media post, or a statement passed through a third person.
Many threats cases arise in a domestic setting and appear on the same complaint as assault and battery on a family or household member. Other threats cases begin with a disagreement between neighbors, coworkers, students, or drivers. A teacher accused of threatening a student can also face a school investigation and action against a teaching license.
The Commonwealth must prove more than the words themselves. The Commonwealth must establish what the defendant meant to communicate, how the statement would reasonably have been understood in context, and what the defendant understood about the threatening character of the statement.
What the Commonwealth Must Prove
The current Massachusetts model jury instruction for threats to commit a crime, revised in February 2026, requires proof of five elements beyond a reasonable doubt.
- The defendant expressed an intent to injure a person or another person’s property, either immediately or in the future.
- The defendant intended the threat to be conveyed to a particular person.
- The threatened injury would constitute a crime if it were carried out.
- The circumstances could reasonably have caused the recipient to fear that the defendant had both the intention and the ability to carry out the threat.
- The defendant was aware of, or consciously disregarded, a substantial risk that the communication would be viewed as threatening violence.
In Commonwealth v. Cruz, 495 Mass. 110 (2024), the Supreme Judicial Court applied Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023), and held that the First Amendment requires proof of the speaker’s subjective awareness, which is the fifth element. It is not enough to show only that a reasonable person could have interpreted the words as threatening.
The Commonwealth does not have to prove that the defendant intended to carry out the threatened crime. The Commonwealth must prove, however, that the defendant understood the risk that the communication would be taken as a threat and delivered the communication anyway.
Penalties and Criminal-Record Consequences
Under G.L. c. 275, § 4, the maximum punishment is a $100 fine or six months in a house of correction. The statute also permits a court, instead of imprisonment, to require a recognizance to keep the peace for up to six months.
The consequences are not limited to the statutory maximum. The charge appears on the court record after arraignment on the complaint, even if the charge is later dismissed. A defendant with a court record of the charge may need a separate analysis of Massachusetts criminal-record access and sealing.
A pending charge or disposition can also affect employment, professional licensing, education, immigration, or firearms licensing. The effects of a pending charge or disposition differ from case to case, so counsel should examine the person’s status before recommending a plea or other disposition.
What Is a “True Threat”?
A conviction requires a true threat, not constitutionally protected speech. A true threat is a serious expression of an intent to commit unlawful violence or injury. Political hyperbole, an obvious joke, angry exaggeration, or crude language is not automatically a true threat.
The court considers the words and the circumstances in which they were used. Relevant facts may include the parties’ history, their tone and physical distance, earlier conduct, the full conversation, and whether the speaker identified a person, act, place, or time.
A conditional statement is not automatically protected or criminal. The question is what the statement conveyed in its full setting, not whether it contained words such as “if” or “unless.”
The recipient does not have to testify that they were afraid. The judge or jury applies an objective test to the fourth element. The question is whether the circumstances could reasonably have caused the recipient to fear that the defendant had the intention and ability to act.
The prosecution also does not have to prove that the defendant possessed the weapon or other means needed to carry out the threat. The issue is whether a reasonable recipient would experience the required apprehension under the surrounding circumstances.
Direct, Indirect, and Third-Party Threats
A threat may be spoken directly to its target, sent in writing, posted online, or communicated through another person. The prosecution must prove that the defendant intended the statement to be conveyed to a particular person, but successful delivery is not always required.
The recipient of the communication and the person threatened with harm may also be different. For example, a threat to injure someone’s child can support a charge based on the fear caused to the person who receives it.
The Commonwealth must identify the particular statement it relies on when a complaint identifies several statements as possible threats. The jurors generally must agree unanimously on the same threatening statement rather than combine different remarks to return a verdict.
Text Messages, Social Media, and Other Digital Evidence
In a case based on digital messages, the defense should review more than a screenshot of a single sentence. The defense should examine the complete exchange and establish who participated and when. The defense should also identify deleted or missing messages and the events that preceded the statement.
Authorship may also be disputed. A displayed name or telephone number does not always establish who wrote a message, who controlled the account, or whether the screenshot is complete and accurate.
The firm’s guide to admitting and objecting to digital evidence in Massachusetts criminal cases explains why authentication, authorship, hearsay, and completeness are separate questions, and how those rules apply to screenshots, platform messages, and phone extractions.
The prosecution and the defense can each use the context of a message. A long exchange may show an escalating and serious threat, or it may show sarcasm, quotation, mutual insults, or a meaning that is not apparent from the isolated screenshot.
Threats Charges in Domestic Violence Cases
In a Massachusetts domestic violence case, police may charge threats even when no physical contact is alleged. The police may also seek a criminal assault charge, while the complainant may request a civil 209A restraining order (abuse prevention order).
The Commonwealth controls the criminal prosecution. A complainant may give the prosecutor new information or decline to support the case, but cannot personally dismiss the charge. The practical consequences of a changed account are explained in the firm’s article on recantation in a Massachusetts domestic violence case.
Contacting a complainant after an arrest can result in a separate charge. A defendant who pressures, persuades, or retaliates against the complainant, or who asks the complainant to withhold information, may face a felony witness-intimidation charge. Any no-contact term in a 209A restraining order remains binding unless a court changes it.
Arrest, Summons, and Clerk-Magistrate Hearings
Chapter 275 does not, by itself, authorize a warrantless arrest for threats to commit a crime. The arrest analysis is different for a domestic incident. Under G.L. c. 209A, § 6, arrest is the preferred response when an officer has probable cause to believe that a person committed a misdemeanor involving abuse as the statute defines it.
Other threats cases may begin with an application for a criminal complaint. Counsel can address probable cause before a complaint issues when a clerk-magistrate hearing under G.L. c. 218, § 35A is available.
A hearing is not guaranteed in every case. A case may instead go directly to arraignment after an arrest, a warrant application, or a judicial determination.
Evidence When the Recipient Does Not Testify
The Commonwealth may prosecute even if the recipient does not testify. The Commonwealth may rely on authenticated messages, recordings, other witnesses, or the defendant’s own admissible statements.
An officer cannot simply repeat every out-of-court accusation. Each statement must satisfy the rules of evidence and, when the statement is testimonial, the Confrontation Clause. A judge may treat a 911 call and a later police interview differently.
The firm’s page on spontaneous or excited utterances in Massachusetts explains how courts analyze 911 calls, on-scene statements, and a non-testifying or recanting witness.
Defenses to a Massachusetts Threats Charge
The defense depends on the statement and its setting. The common issues are listed below.
- No threatened crime. The statement may express anger or predict a lawful consequence without threatening conduct that would be criminal.
- No intent to convey the statement. The Commonwealth may be unable to prove the second element for a private remark that the defendant did not intend to be conveyed to a particular person.
- No true threat. The language, tone, audience, or surrounding events may show protected hyperbole, humor, venting, or ambiguity rather than a serious threat.
- No required subjective awareness. The evidence may not prove that the defendant knew of, or consciously disregarded, the substantial risk that the statement would be understood as threatening violence.
- No objectively reasonable apprehension. The circumstances may not support a reasonable fear that the defendant had both the intention and the ability to act.
- Identity or authentication problems. The Commonwealth must connect the defendant to a disputed account, message, recording, or post.
- Incomplete context. A cropped screenshot or partial recording may omit language that changes the meaning of the statement.
Some cases present several of these issues at once. The defense should identify the precise words the Commonwealth relies on and test each element against that statement.
How Attorney Serpa Approaches a Threats Case
Attorney Serpa begins each review with the exact alleged statement. Attorney Serpa obtains the complete message thread or recording, along with police reports and available witness accounts. He then compares that evidence with all five required elements.
The first objective may be to prevent a complaint from issuing when a clerk-magistrate hearing is available. After arraignment, the work may include a motion to dismiss or another dismissal strategy, an evidentiary motion, trial preparation, or a negotiated resolution that accounts for the client’s record and professional circumstances.
Serpa Law Office represents people charged in the Boston Municipal Court and in District Courts throughout Greater Boston and Massachusetts. For a confidential consultation about a threats allegation, call 617.936.0201.
Frequently Asked Questions About Threats Charges
A text message can be a threat to commit a crime. A threat may be spoken, written, texted, posted online, or passed through another person. The Commonwealth must prove the same five elements for a text as for a spoken statement. Two of the five elements require proof that the defendant intended the message to be conveyed to a particular person and was aware of, or consciously disregarded, a substantial risk that the message would be read as threatening violence. The judge or jury decides what the message conveyed from the complete thread, not from a cropped screenshot. The Commonwealth must also prove who wrote the message.
A joke, hyperbole, venting, or crude language that, in context, does not convey a real possibility that violence will follow is not a true threat and is protected by the First Amendment. Under Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023), and Commonwealth v. Cruz, 495 Mass. 110 (2024), the Commonwealth must prove that the defendant was at least reckless about the threatening character of the words. Recklessness here means that the defendant knew of a substantial risk that the statement would be taken as a threat of violence and made the statement anyway. The judge or jury decides whether the defendant was reckless based on the words, the tone, the history between the parties, and the full exchange.
No. Threats to commit a crime under G.L. c. 275, § 2 is a misdemeanor. The maximum penalty under § 4 is a fine of $100 or six months in the house of correction. The judge may instead require a recognizance to keep the peace for up to six months. The Commonwealth may also bring a felony charge for the same statement under a different statute. For example, the Commonwealth may charge intimidation of a witness under G.L. c. 268, § 13B, when the threat concerns a witness, or stalking when the statement is part of a pattern.
A defendant convicted of threats to commit a crime under G.L. c. 275, § 2 faces a fine of up to $100 or up to six months in a house of correction under G.L. c. 275, § 4. The judge may instead order the defendant to post a recognizance to keep the peace for up to six months. The charge is a misdemeanor. The arraignment creates a CORI entry even when the charge is later dismissed. A conviction can also affect employment, a professional license, immigration status, and a firearms license.
Five elements, each beyond a reasonable doubt. First, the defendant expressed an intent to injure a person or another person’s property, now or in the future. Second, the defendant intended the threat to be conveyed to a particular person. Third, the threatened injury would be a crime if carried out. Fourth, the circumstances could reasonably have caused the recipient to fear that the defendant had both the intention and the ability to carry out the threat. Fifth, the defendant was aware of, or consciously disregarded, a substantial risk that the communication would be viewed as threatening violence. Commonwealth v. Cruz, 495 Mass. 110.
A serious expression of an intent to commit unlawful violence or injury. Political hyperbole, an obvious joke, angry exaggeration, and crude language are not true threats. The First Amendment protects them. The judge or jury considers the words and their setting: the history between the parties, tone, distance, earlier conduct, the full conversation, and whether the speaker named a person, an act, a place, or a time. A conditional statement with “if” or “unless” can still be a true threat. The Commonwealth must also prove that the defendant knew of, or consciously disregarded, the risk that the words would be taken as a threat.
No. The Commonwealth does not have to prove that the defendant intended to carry out the threatened crime, or that the defendant had the weapon or means to do so. The Commonwealth must prove that the defendant intended the statement to be conveyed to a particular person, that the circumstances could reasonably cause that person to fear the defendant had the intention and ability to act, and that the defendant was aware of, or consciously disregarded, a substantial risk that the statement would be understood as threatening violence. Commonwealth v. Cruz, 495 Mass. 110, applying Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66.
Yes, if the Commonwealth proves that you intended the statement to be conveyed to the person threatened. A threat spoken to a friend, posted online, or sent to a relative can support the charge when the defendant intended it to be conveyed to a particular person, even if the message never arrived. The recipient and the person threatened with harm can also be different people: a threat to hurt someone’s child can support a charge based on the fear caused to the parent who received it. A private remark the defendant never intended anyone to pass along does not satisfy the second element.
Chapter 275 itself does not authorize a warrantless arrest for threats, so a threats case that arises outside a domestic setting ordinarily begins with an application for a criminal complaint and a clerk-magistrate hearing under G.L. c. 218, § 35A, where counsel can argue that the statement was not a true threat before any complaint issues. In a domestic case, arrest is the preferred response under G.L. c. 209A, § 6 when an officer has probable cause to believe that a person committed a misdemeanor involving abuse, and the case goes directly to arraignment.
No. The Commonwealth may prove the charge with authenticated text messages, recordings, social media posts, other witnesses, and the defendant’s own statements. The recipient does not have to testify to fear, because the fourth element is judged objectively. An officer cannot simply repeat every accusation, however. Each out-of-court statement must satisfy the rules of evidence. A statement made to the police to report past events is testimonial under the Confrontation Clause and cannot be used without the witness. A 911 call made during an emergency is treated differently from a later police interview.
Yes, from the arraignment. The charge appears on CORI from the arraignment on the complaint, even when the charge is later dismissed. A complaint application that the clerk-magistrate denies creates no entry. A judge can seal a dismissed charge or a not guilty finding under G.L. c. 276, § 100C. The Commissioner of Probation seals a misdemeanor conviction on request after three years under G.L. c. 276, § 100A, if the person has no new conviction during the waiting period. A standard CORI report seen by most employers does not include a sealed record.
Yes, in several ways. A clerk-magistrate can deny the complaint application after a hearing, so no case begins. After arraignment, counsel can move to dismiss when the statement, read in its full context, is not a true threat or when the application does not show probable cause on each of the five elements. The Commonwealth may dismiss a case when it cannot authenticate a message or connect the defendant to the account. The judge may also place the defendant on pretrial probation under G.L. c. 276, § 87 with the Commonwealth’s agreement, with a dismissal at the end of the term.











