Defense Lawyer
What to Do When Under Criminal Investigation in Massachusetts Before Charges Are Filed
A detective leaves a voicemail and asks for a call back. Two officers come to the door with a few questions. A sergeant asks a person to come to the station to answer questions about an incident. Officers arrive with a search warrant and leave with a phone and a laptop. A grand jury subpoena arrives in the mail.
Each of these events begins a Massachusetts criminal investigation before any arrest and before any charge. A person in that position can retain a criminal defense lawyer at once. A lawyer retained at this stage advises the person on whether to speak with the detective, examines the search warrant, prepares the person for a grand jury appearance, preserves the evidence that helps the person, and prepares to oppose a criminal complaint at a clerk-magistrate hearing.
Attorney Joe Serpa has practiced Massachusetts criminal defense since 1995. He advises people who are under investigation in Boston, Quincy, Cambridge, and the district courts of eastern Massachusetts. He also represents them at the clerk-magistrate hearing, at arraignment, and at every later stage described in the firm’s Massachusetts criminal process guide.
A Detective Calls or Asks for an Interview at the Police Station
A person who receives a call from a detective has no legal duty to return the call, to answer questions, or to go to the police station for an interview. A detective’s request for an interview is an invitation that the person may decline. A subpoena or a court order is a command that the person must obey. Counsel can read the paperwork, identify whether the person has received a request or a command, and tell the person what to do in response.
The person should call a lawyer before calling the detective back. Counsel can then call the detective, learn which agency is investigating and what the detective wants to discuss, and advise the person whether to give a statement, to answer written questions, or to communicate only through counsel. Many investigations end without a charge. The police, however, can use a statement given without advice to support a complaint application. Officers often record the interview. The Commonwealth may then play the recording at trial.
Under Mass. R. Crim. P. 14, the Commonwealth turns over police reports, witness statements, and other discovery only after arraignment, at or before the pretrial conference. Before charges, the police keep their file to themselves. The police also continue the investigation after the person retains a lawyer. Counsel instead gathers information from the client, from witnesses, and from documents, investigates independently, and decides whether to present favorable evidence to the detective or to the prosecutor.
A Witness, a Suspect, or a Target
Police often tell a person that the investigation concerns someone else and that the person is “only a witness.” A person described as a witness today can become a suspect after the interview. The Commonwealth can use the person’s own text messages, social media posts, relationships, and whereabouts as evidence against that person, even when every question seemed to be about a friend, a coworker, or a family member. Counsel assesses the person’s own criminal exposure before the person answers a single substantive question.
The same caution applies to a person who knows that an accusation is false. The police still investigate a false accusation of assault, sexual assault, theft, or fraud. The investigating officer decides what the report says. An innocent explanation given without preparation can be recorded inaccurately, contradicted by a detail the person forgot, or used to establish that the person was present when the alleged event occurred. Counsel decides how and when to give the person’s account to the police.
Voluntary Interviews, Custody, and Miranda Warnings
Police must give Miranda warnings before a custodial interrogation. A person is in custody when a reasonable person in that position would believe that they were not free to leave. The Supreme Judicial Court considers where the questioning takes place, whether the officers have conveyed to the person that they consider the person a suspect, whether the questioning is aggressive or informal, and whether the person is free to end the interview by leaving or by asking the officers to leave. Commonwealth v. Groome, 435 Mass. 201, 211-212 (2001).
An interview at a police station is not automatically custodial. In Groome, the Supreme Judicial Court held that a man who rode with officers to the state police barracks voluntarily, was told that he was free to leave, and was allowed to leave the interview room unescorted was not in custody until the trooper questioning him learned of new evidence, decided to arrest him, and confronted him with that evidence. Id. at 213-217.
Police must give Miranda warnings only before a custodial interrogation. A person in a voluntary interview may therefore receive no reminder of the right to remain silent. A person in a voluntary interview can decline to discuss the facts, can end the conversation, and can leave. During a custodial interrogation, the person should say clearly that they will not answer questions or that they want a lawyer, and should then stop talking. The firm’s page on the right to remain silent in Massachusetts explains how to invoke that right and what happens after a person invokes it.
Article 12 of the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights gives a person under custodial interrogation a protection beyond Miranda. When a lawyer calls the police station or arrives there and says that the lawyer represents the person being questioned, the police must stop the questioning and tell the person immediately that the lawyer is trying to speak with them. If the person accepts the lawyer’s help, the police must suspend the questioning until the person has had the opportunity to consult the lawyer by telephone or in person. Commonwealth v. Mavredakis, 430 Mass. 848, 858-861 (2000).
For that reason, a family member who learns that a relative is being questioned at a police station should call a lawyer at once. The lawyer’s call to the station then requires the police to stop the questioning and tell the relative that the lawyer is trying to speak with them.
The person being questioned must still invoke the right to remain silent and the right to counsel personally. Commonwealth v. Beland, 436 Mass. 273, 288 (2002). In Commonwealth v. Collins, 440 Mass. 475, 478-481 (2003), the Supreme Judicial Court reversed an order suppressing the statement of a man who had already retained and consulted a lawyer about the investigation, waived his rights, and spoke to the police, even though the police had not told him that the lawyer had asked days earlier to be present at any interview.
A lawyer’s advance letter or telephone call to the police does not invoke the client’s rights for the client. In Massachusetts, the right to counsel under the Sixth Amendment and article 12 begins at arraignment or indictment. The right does not begin when a complaint or an arrest warrant issues. Beland, 436 Mass. at 285. Before arraignment or indictment, Miranda and article 12 govern police questioning.
Search Warrants at a Home, a Business, or a Car
Officers who execute a search warrant may enter and search the place the warrant names and may seize the items the warrant describes. G.L. c. 276, § 2 requires the warrant to identify the place to be searched and to describe particularly the property to be seized. Section 2B requires the person seeking the warrant to give a sworn affidavit setting out the facts on which that person relies. The judge or clerk-magistrate who issues the warrant decides from that affidavit alone whether probable cause exists.
Counsel obtains the warrant, the affidavit, and the return, and examines whether the affidavit established probable cause, whether the search stayed within the warrant, and what the officers took. If the affidavit did not establish probable cause, or the officers searched beyond the warrant, counsel files a motion to suppress once the Commonwealth brings a charge.
A person whose home is searched should read the warrant, keep the copy and the inventory that the officers leave behind, and stay out of the officers’ way. A person who interferes with officers executing a warrant can face a separate criminal charge. The person may refuse to consent to any search beyond what the warrant authorizes. The officers may still execute the warrant as written.
Police may also search without a warrant in specific situations, such as a search with consent or a search incident to an arrest. The firm’s search and seizure page explains those exceptions and the motion to suppress.
A Seized Phone, Computer, or Passcode Request
Officers who seize a phone or a computer may hold the device, but they must ordinarily obtain a warrant that authorizes a search of the device before they search its contents. The exceptions are the owner’s consent and an emergency that requires an immediate search. Counsel examines the warrant’s description of the accounts, applications, and dates that the officers may search. The firm’s page on phone and computer searches explains the particularity rules that Massachusetts courts apply to digital searches.
A detective’s request for a passcode is a request for consent that the person may refuse. A court order compelling a person to enter a passcode is a command. Under Commonwealth v. Jones, 481 Mass. 540 (2019), a judge may order a person to enter the passcode only after the Commonwealth proves beyond a reasonable doubt that the person knows the passcode. The firm’s post on police requests for an iPhone passcode explains that rule and the privilege against self-incrimination that underlies it.
A Grand Jury Subpoena or a Target Letter
A person who receives a grand jury subpoena must appear on the date the subpoena states and must bring any records it demands, unless a judge excuses or modifies the subpoena first. The privilege against self-incrimination gives the witness the right to refuse to answer particular questions. The privilege does not excuse the witness from appearing. Counsel reviews the subpoena, identifies the questions or records that could incriminate the client, and, where the law supports a motion, moves to quash or modify the subpoena before the return date.
In a Massachusetts grand jury, a witness may have a lawyer in the grand jury room. G.L. c. 277, § 14A. The lawyer may advise the witness during the testimony but may not object, argue, or address the prosecutor or the grand jurors. A witness may not refuse to appear because the witness’s lawyer is unavailable. A witness subpoenaed to the federal grand jury in Boston, by contrast, consults counsel outside the grand jury room.
A prosecutor has no constitutional duty to tell a witness that the witness is a target of the investigation. The Supreme Judicial Court nevertheless requires a Massachusetts prosecutor who has reason to believe that a witness is a target, or is likely to become one, to warn the witness before the testimony begins that the witness may refuse to answer any question whose truthful answer would tend to incriminate the witness, and that anything the witness says may be used against the witness in a later proceeding. Commonwealth v. Woods, 466 Mass. 707, 716-720 (2014).
A prosecutor sometimes sends a target letter with the subpoena or instead of one. A target letter tells the person that the prosecutor considers the person a likely defendant. A person who receives a target letter should retain counsel before responding.
A witness may refuse to give incriminating testimony. The privilege protects the production of documents in narrower circumstances than it protects testimony. Counsel therefore assesses each demand for records separately rather than assuming that every document is protected. The firm’s grand jury and indictment page explains how a grand jury indictment begins a Superior Court prosecution.
Preserving Text Messages, Video, and Other Evidence
A person under investigation should keep every text message, photograph, voicemail, social media post, account record, and receipt that concerns the events, and should delete nothing. A complete message thread shows the context that a single screenshot leaves out.
Counsel can send a preservation letter to a store, a bar, a building manager, a rideshare company, or a cellular carrier before surveillance video or account records are overwritten in the ordinary course of business, and can interview witnesses while their memories are fresh. The firm’s page on digital evidence in Massachusetts criminal cases explains how the Commonwealth and the defense authenticate messages and recordings at trial.
A person who deletes or hides evidence can be charged with a separate crime. G.L. c. 268, § 13E makes it a felony to alter, destroy, mutilate, or conceal a record, document, or other object, or to attempt to do so, with intent to impair its integrity or availability for use in an official proceeding, whether or not the proceeding is pending at the time. A person who wipes a phone or deletes a message thread after learning of an investigation can therefore face a tampering charge in addition to the original allegation.
A person who asks a witness to change an account, to stay quiet, or to withdraw a complaint can be charged with intimidation of a witness under G.L. c. 268, § 13B. Any contact that a restraining order prohibits also violates the order. Counsel gathers evidence from witnesses lawfully, through an investigator or a subpoena, so that the person under investigation never negotiates with a witness about testimony.
Clerk-Magistrate Hearings, Arrest Warrants, and Arraignment
Many Massachusetts investigations end with a police officer filing an application for a criminal complaint rather than with an arrest. For a misdemeanor, a person who is not under arrest ordinarily receives notice and an opportunity to oppose the complaint at a clerk-magistrate hearing before any complaint issues. G.L. c. 218, § 35A. The clerk-magistrate ordinarily holds the hearing in private, before any arraignment. If the clerk-magistrate denies the application, no complaint issues, no arraignment occurs, and no entry appears on the person’s criminal record from that application.
Under § 35A, the clerk-magistrate may issue the complaint without a hearing where there is an imminent threat of bodily injury, of the commission of a crime, or of flight from the Commonwealth. For a felony application filed by a police officer, the clerk-magistrate holds a hearing when the officer requests one. Counsel prepares the evidence and the argument for the hearing. In Attorney Serpa’s experience, the clerk-magistrate hearing is often the proceeding at which the matter ends without a complaint.
Where police seek an arrest warrant or plan an arrest, counsel can arrange for the person to appear in court voluntarily rather than be arrested at home or at work, and can prepare the argument on bail and conditions of release for the arraignment. The firm’s page on warrants and arrests explains how a judge or a clerk-magistrate issues a warrant and what happens when police execute one.
A hearing notice means that no complaint has issued yet. A summons for arraignment means that the clerk-magistrate has already issued the complaint. The arraignment itself creates the entry on the person’s criminal record.
School, Employer, and Licensing Board Investigations
A college, an employer, or a professional licensing board may investigate the same conduct at the same time as the police. Each has its own rules on whether an allegation, an arrest, a pending charge, an admission, a conviction, a continuance without a finding, or a dismissal must be disclosed and on what discipline may follow. The prosecutor can obtain a statement given to a dean, a human resources investigator, or a board investigator and use the statement in the criminal case. Counsel coordinates the timing and the content of every response.
The firm’s college and university student defense page explains the student conduct proceedings that run alongside a police investigation. The professional license page identifies the disclosure and discipline rules for nurses, teachers, lawyers, and other licensed professionals. For conduct alleged to have occurred before the person turned eighteen, the firm’s juvenile delinquency and youthful offender page explains the Juvenile Court rules on questioning, diversion, and records.
Speaking With a Criminal Investigation Lawyer in Boston
At a first consultation, Attorney Serpa reviews the agency involved, the kind of contact, any deadline or return date, any search warrant or subpoena paperwork, and any existing court order. Serpa Law Office represents people under investigation in Boston, Quincy, and across eastern Massachusetts, from the first call from a detective through the clerk-magistrate hearing, the arraignment, and trial. Request a free, confidential consultation before speaking with the police.
Frequently Asked Questions
A person has no legal duty to return a detective’s call, to go to the police station, or to answer questions. A detective’s request for an interview is an invitation. A subpoena or a court order is a command, and the person must comply with it. The better course is to have a lawyer call the detective, learn what the investigation concerns, and advise whether to give any statement at all.
A person under investigation can retain a lawyer before any charge. Before charges, a lawyer can decline the interview on the client’s behalf, examine a search warrant, prepare the client for a grand jury appearance, preserve helpful evidence, and oppose the complaint at a clerk-magistrate hearing, where a denial means that no complaint issues. After arraignment, the case is already on the person’s criminal record.
A person whom police describe as a witness can become a suspect after the interview. The person’s own messages, relationships, and whereabouts can become evidence, and the Commonwealth can use a witness’s recorded statement against that witness later. A lawyer assesses the person’s own exposure before the person answers substantive questions.
A lawyer cannot order the police to close an investigation. A lawyer can keep the client from giving a statement that the Commonwealth can use as evidence, can present favorable evidence to the detective or the prosecutor, and, for most misdemeanor applications, can oppose the complaint at a clerk-magistrate hearing. If the clerk-magistrate denies the application, no complaint issues and no arraignment occurs.
Police must ordinarily obtain a warrant that authorizes a search of the device before they search the contents of a seized phone, unless the owner consents or an emergency requires an immediate search. A request for a passcode is a request for consent, which the person may refuse. A judge may order a person to enter a passcode only after the Commonwealth proves beyond a reasonable doubt that the person knows it. Counsel examines whether the warrant limits the search to particular accounts, applications, and dates.
A person who receives a grand jury subpoena must appear. The witness may refuse to answer a particular question when a truthful answer would tend to incriminate the witness, and a Massachusetts witness may have a lawyer inside the grand jury room under G.L. c. 277, § 14A. Counsel reviews the subpoena before the return date and, where the law supports it, moves to quash or modify it.
No, unless the officers have a warrant. A person has no legal duty to open the door, to step outside, or to answer questions when officers knock without a warrant. The person may speak through the closed door. The person may ask whether the officers have a warrant. The person may say that the person will not answer questions without a lawyer. When the officers have a search warrant or an arrest warrant, the person must let them in and must not interfere. The person should read the warrant, keep the copy the officers leave, and call a lawyer.
No. A detective’s request for a passcode is a request for consent. The person may refuse. The police may hold the phone and apply for a warrant to search its contents. A court order compelling the person to enter the passcode is different. Under Commonwealth v. Jones, 481 Mass. 540, a judge may order a person to enter a passcode only after the Commonwealth proves beyond a reasonable doubt that the person knows the passcode. The privilege against self-incrimination underlies that rule. A person who receives a court order should bring it to a lawyer at once.
There is no fixed deadline for the police to finish an investigation. The only outer limit is the statute of limitations in G.L. c. 277, § 63, which gives the Commonwealth six years from the alleged offense to bring most charges. Certain offenses, including murder and some sexual offenses, have longer periods or no limit. Many investigations end within weeks. Others continue for months while the police wait for phone records, laboratory results, or a witness. A lawyer retained during the investigation can call the detective and learn whether the investigation is still open.
For a misdemeanor, ordinarily yes. Under G.L. c. 218, § 35A, a person accused of a misdemeanor who was not arrested receives notice of a clerk-magistrate hearing before any complaint issues. The person may attend the hearing with a lawyer and oppose the complaint. For a felony, the clerk-magistrate may issue the complaint without notice when the police ask, and the person first learns of the charge from a summons to arraignment or from an arrest. A lawyer who has already contacted the police can ask that the client be summonsed rather than arrested and can arrange the client’s appearance in court.
No. A person who deletes, destroys, or hides a message, a photograph, a video, or a record with the intent to keep it out of an official proceeding can be charged with a felony under G.L. c. 268, § 13E, whether or not the proceeding has begun. A person who wipes a phone after learning of an investigation faces a tampering charge in addition to the original allegation. The person should keep every message, photograph, voicemail, and account record that concerns the events. A complete message thread shows the context that a single screenshot leaves out.
Yes. The call changes what the police must do. Under article 12 of the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights, when a lawyer calls or arrives at the police station and says that the lawyer represents the person being questioned, the police must stop and tell the person at once that the lawyer is trying to speak with them. Commonwealth v. Mavredakis, 430 Mass. 848. If the person accepts the lawyer’s help, the police must suspend the questioning until the person has spoken with the lawyer by telephone or in person. The person must still say personally that the person wants a lawyer.
Related Serpa Law Office Resources
- Massachusetts Criminal Process: From Clerk-Magistrate Hearing to Trial and Appeal
- Your Right to Remain Silent in Massachusetts
- Illegal Searches and Seizures in Massachusetts
- Phone and Computer Searches in Massachusetts
- Massachusetts Clerk-Magistrate Hearing Lawyer
- Massachusetts Grand Jury Indictments: How Superior Court Cases Begin
- Warrants and Arrests in Massachusetts District Courts and the Boston Municipal Court
- How Criminal Cases Begin in the District and Boston Municipal Courts
- Arraignment in Massachusetts: What Happens and What It Means for Your Record
- Massachusetts Bail: Release, Conditions, and Review
- Digital Evidence in Massachusetts Criminal Cases











