Defense Lawyer
Massachusetts Sealing and Expungement Standards: Eligibility, Exclusions, and Federal Records
A person with a Massachusetts criminal record often asks when the record can be sealed, which crimes can be expunged, and what the difference is between sealing and expungement. The answer depends on how the case ended, how long ago the case ended, the person’s age at the time of the offense, and the rest of the person’s record. Massachusetts law sets a different waiting period and a different list of excluded offenses for each kind of relief.
Sealing restricts who can see a record. Most employers, landlords, and licensing boards who ask about a sealed record receive a report that no record exists. The person may also answer “no record” on an application for a job, housing, or a professional license. Expungement goes further than sealing. Expungement destroys the record in Massachusetts state and local systems, but expungement is available in narrower circumstances than sealing.
The Commissioner of Probation seals an eligible conviction under M.G.L. c. 276, § 100A after a waiting period of three years for a misdemeanor and seven years for a felony. Section 100C governs the sealing of non-conviction records, such as a not guilty verdict, a dismissal, or a nolle prosequi. Sections 100F through 100J allow time-based expungement of a limited record of offenses committed before age twenty-one. Section 100K allows expungement of a record created by error, fraud, false identification, or conduct that is no longer a crime.
The sections below explain the waiting periods, eligibility rules, and excluded offenses for each kind of relief, the grounds for expungement, and how a Massachusetts order affects an FBI record. The client guide, Sealing and Expunging a Massachusetts Criminal Record, explains how a person asks for sealing or expungement. How Massachusetts Judges Decide Sealing and Expungement Petitions explains the burden of proof, the factors the judge weighs, and the evidence that supports a petition.
Time-Based Sealing Under M.G.L. c. 276, § 100A
Section 100A requires a person seeking conviction sealing to submit a request to the Commissioner of Probation. A qualifying misdemeanor record becomes eligible three years after the court appearance and disposition, including any period of incarceration or custody. A qualifying felony record becomes eligible after seven years. A new conviction or period of incarceration within the applicable period may delay eligibility.
Section 100A generally requires fifteen years before the Commissioner may seal an eligible sex-offense record. The Commissioner cannot seal the record while any registration duty continues. A person whom the Sex Offender Registry Board has ever classified as Level 2 or Level 3 cannot seal the sex offense under § 100A. The Commissioner must seal the record when the person satisfies every requirement and no statutory exclusion applies. A judge cannot shorten the § 100A waiting period.
Non-Conviction Sealing Under M.G.L. c. 276, § 100C
Section 100C requires sealing after a not-guilty finding, grand-jury no bill, or judicial finding of no probable cause unless the defendant submits a written request not to seal the record. A person seeking to seal a dismissal or nolle prosequi must petition the court. The judge may order sealing when substantial justice would best be served. The judicial-decision guide explains the Pon factors, burden, and evidence for a discretionary petition.
What Expungement Removes
Expungement permanently erases or destroys a covered record from Massachusetts state and local systems. Under M.G.L. c. 276, § 100L, expungement includes covered publicly available police logs. The statutory definition excludes the statewide domestic-violence record-keeping system. Massachusetts relief also does not necessarily remove a federal record or a record that a private entity independently preserved.
Sections 100F through 100J govern time-based expungement. Section 100K governs expungement based on a qualifying error, fraud, false identification, or decriminalized conduct.
Time-Based Expungement Under Sections 100F Through 100J
Time-based expungement covers petitioned offenses committed before the person’s twenty-first birthday. At least three years must have passed for misdemeanor-only records and seven years if any petitioned record includes a felony. The calculation includes connected periods of custody and probation.
The petition may include no more than two records of the applicable type, and multiple charges from one incident count as one record. Other than motor-vehicle matters for which the punishment was no more than a $50 fine, the person must have no other criminal or juvenile court appearances or dispositions in Massachusetts, another state, a United States possession, or federal court. The person must also certify that, to the person’s knowledge, no criminal-justice agency is conducting an active investigation.
Section 100J contains twenty categories excluded from time-based expungement. The categories include offenses involving death or serious bodily injury, offenses committed while armed with a dangerous weapon, sex offenses, OUI, specified firearms and weapons offenses, listed protective-order violations, M.G.L. c. 265, § 13M, and any felony under chapter 265.
The Commissioner of Probation first determines statutory eligibility. For an eligible record, the Commissioner notifies the district attorney, who may object. A judge then decides whether expungement serves the best interests of justice. Time-based expungement is often of particular use to students and young professionals who have very limited records from before age twenty-one and whose applications require an accurate review of the record. The firm’s student defense FAQs address record disclosure questions on applications.
Reason-Based Expungement Under Section 100K
Section 100K does not impose the age, waiting-period, record-count, or offense-exclusion rules in §§ 100I and 100J. The petitioner must prove a qualifying ground by clear and convincing evidence. The qualifying grounds are that the record resulted from false identification or identity theft, conduct that is no longer criminal, demonstrable error by law enforcement, a civilian or expert witness, or a court employee, or fraud upon the court.
In Commonwealth v. K.W., 490 Mass. 619 (2022), the Supreme Judicial Court held that a strong presumption favors expungement after the petitioner proves a qualifying ground under § 100K(a) by clear and convincing evidence. Absent a substantial countervailing concern, the judge must grant the petition. This presumption applies only to reason-based expungement under § 100K, not to time-based expungement.
In K.W., the Supreme Judicial Court also limited what the judge may consider. The judge may not weigh the petitioner’s other criminal records against expungement of the qualifying record. The petitioner also need not prove the particular disadvantage required for sealing a dismissal under § 100C.
The court must hold a hearing if the petitioner or district attorney requests one. A judge who denies an otherwise qualifying petition because of a substantial countervailing concern must enter written findings that identify the concern and explain the denial. A judge who grants expungement under § 100K must enter written findings of fact.
M.G.L. c. 276, § 100K 1/4 separately requires expungement of specified marijuana possession, cultivation, possession with intent to distribute, and distribution records based on amounts later decriminalized by the statutes identified in that provision.
Noncitizens should obtain immigration advice before filing either type of petition, because federal immigration law has its own definition of a conviction. Federal immigration authorities do not necessarily treat Massachusetts record relief as eliminating the disposition. The firm’s page on immigration consequences explains the federal immigration definition of a conviction. A motion under the SJC’s Chhieng decision may address an older conviction more directly than sealing or expungement when the court accepted the plea without the required immigration warning.
Convictions Excluded From Section 100A Sealing
M.G.L. c. 276, § 100A excludes convictions under M.G.L. c. 140, §§ 121 through 131H, which cover specified firearms laws, and convictions under chapters 268 and 268A, which cover crimes against public justice and public-employee ethics offenses. Resisting arrest is an express exception. The Commissioner may seal a resisting arrest conviction after the applicable waiting period.
A sex offense cannot be sealed while a registration duty continues. A person whom the Sex Offender Registry Board has ever classified as a Level 2 or Level 3 sex offender cannot seal the sex offense under § 100A. Section 100A does not categorically exclude murder by name. These conviction-sealing exclusions do not govern the sealing of a non-conviction disposition under § 100C or reason-based expungement on a separate § 100K ground.
Employment, Licensing, and Education Questions
Private employers, licensing boards, schools, federal agencies, security-clearance authorities, and immigration agencies may ask different questions and may have different access to sealed records. For inquiries governed by the Massachusetts sealing statutes, a person with a sealed record generally may answer “no record.” A board or federal agency may apply a different disclosure rule or ask about the underlying conduct.
The firm’s pages for licensed professionals, professional-license consequences, and student defense explain the different disclosure rules. Expungement erases the covered Massachusetts state and local records, but federal agencies, civil registries, and private background-screening companies may continue to maintain separate records.
FBI Rap Sheets and Federal Background Checks
A Massachusetts order to seal or expunge controls the Massachusetts records covered by the order. The FBI creates a separate Identity History Summary from fingerprint submissions. M.G.L. c. 22C, § 36 requires Massachusetts to transmit case dispositions and sealing or expungement orders when Massachusetts previously transmitted fingerprints to the FBI. M.G.L. c. 276, § 100T also requires notice to the FBI and the United States Department of Justice and a request that the corresponding federal record be sealed or expunged. A Massachusetts judge cannot command a federal court or federal agency to change an independently maintained record.
A federal background check displays the information that Massachusetts and other agencies transmitted to the federal system. The federal record may remain incomplete if Massachusetts never transmitted the later disposition or sealing or expungement order. Federal employment, immigration, security-clearance, and regulated-industry applications may also ask questions broader than a Massachusetts CORI inquiry. The applicant must base each answer on the actual federal record and the rule governing the application. The applicant should not assume that a federal agency will ignore a state order or must follow it.
A person may obtain an FBI Identity History Summary under 28 C.F.R. § 16.32. A person whose FBI entry is incomplete or inaccurate may use the correction procedure in 28 C.F.R. § 16.34, which involves the agency that contributed the information. A person may need certified Massachusetts disposition and record-order documents to establish the requested update. The firm’s page on Massachusetts sealing orders and federal criminal records explains the federal correction procedure.
Sealing a Massachusetts record does not remove news coverage or every record that a private source lawfully retained. The criminal-record expungement statutes do not cover information stored in the statewide domestic-violence record-keeping system for 209A restraining orders and 258E harassment prevention orders. The Supreme Judicial Court held in Piper P. v. Barron B., SJC-13854, that a court cannot expunge a harassment prevention order from the statewide registry after a judge vacates the order for insufficient evidence, the same rule the Court adopted for abuse prevention orders in Vaccaro v. Vaccaro, 425 Mass. 153 (1997). A judge may expunge either kind of order only on clear and convincing evidence of fraud on the court. The firm’s page on Massachusetts domestic-violence records, CORI, and the statewide registry explains how the statewide registry differs from a criminal record.
Preventing a CORI Entry Before Arraignment
A person who is never arraigned ordinarily has no CORI entry from a complaint application. No criminal complaint, arraignment, or CORI entry results from an eligible complaint application that a clerk-magistrate denies. A defendant may also avoid a CORI entry from a complaint that a judge dismisses before arraignment.
Stopping a complaint before arraignment does not erase police reports, arrest information, fingerprint records, school files, licensing records, or information that federal or immigration agencies already possess. Serpa Law Office represents clients at eligible prearraignment clerk-magistrate hearings and seeks denial of the complaint application before a public criminal case begins. The firm’s page on how Massachusetts criminal cases can be dismissed or stopped before trial explains the available procedures. The firm’s case results include complaint applications denied before arraignment.
The sealing and expungement standards on this page apply to criminal records. The Commissioner of Probation keeps the records of 209A restraining orders and 258E harassment prevention orders in a separate statewide civil registry. The § 100A waiting periods, § 100C good-cause standard, and § 100K grounds do not govern that registry. The firm’s page on expunging a 209A restraining order or 258E harassment prevention order from the registry explains the fraud-on-the-court standard for removing a civil-order entry.
Related Serpa Law Office Resources
- Sealing and Expunging a Massachusetts Criminal Record
- Sealing Dismissals and CWOFs in Massachusetts: A Practitioner’s Guide
- How Massachusetts Judges Decide Sealing and Expungement Petitions
- Sealing and Expungement FAQs
- Your Massachusetts Criminal Record and CORI
- The Gravito Decision on Sealed-Record Access
- Clerk-Magistrate Hearings in Massachusetts
- Continuance Without a Finding, Pretrial Probation, and Diversion
Contact Serpa Law Office at 617.936.0201 or contact the firm online for a confidential consultation. The Boston office is at 20 Park Plaza, Suite 400A. The Quincy Office is at 500 Victory Road, Suite 400A.










